2009 Preview: Baseball’s Top Bullpens

Where do the Twins and baseballs best closer rank? (gamergirl27/Flickr)

Where do the Twins and baseball's best closer rank? (gamergirl27/Flickr)

Often the most overlooked part of a team’s success is also often the most valuable. In this case, it’s usually the bullpen.

The bullpen isn’t as sexy as a powerful or fast lineup and it’s not as glamorous as a dominating rotation. But in this day in age where starting pitchers have become coddled and pitch fewer innings each game, bullpens have had to get 9-12 outs per game now and having it loaded with reliable arms is more important than ever.

With that being said, I figured the best way to start our 2009 Preview series (one of this site’s most popular series) is to take a look at the top five bullpens in all of baseball.

[5] Chicago Cubs
With the Cubs not bringing back their closer Kerry Wood, the spot has been seemingly opened up for hard throwing right hander, Carlos Marmol. But the winter addition of Florida Marlins closer Kevin Gregg has added some competition for the ninth inning gig. These two will battle this spring, one with power on his side and the other with experience, with the winner getting the nod from skipper Lou Pinella. Don’t be surprised if Gregg wins this job with Pinella’s track record favoring veterans. Also make sure to keep an eye on the youngster Jeff Samardzija this season as he could be the closer in the making.
Closer: Kevin Gregg (R)/Carlos Marmol (R)
Set-up: Carlos Marmol (R)/Kevin Gregg (R)
Impact Arm: Jeff Samardzija (R)
The Rest: Aaron Heilman (R), Luis Vizcaino (R), Neal Cotts (L), Chad Gaudin (R)

[4] Philadelphia Phillies
It’s hard not to put these guys in the top five considering they had one of the best set-up men in baseball (Ryan Madson) and a closer who was perfect right up until the final pitch of the World Series (Brad Lidge) last season. Lidge seems to have gotten over the Pujols shot heard round the world that seemingly crushed his confidence back in the 2005 NLCS and was able to become the most reliable closer in the game. The Phillies had inklings of making Madson a starter until he became an indispensable 8th inning guy. The Phillies pulled in the number four spot even without the cheater JC Romero who won’t be back until mid season due to his suspension.
Closer: Brad Lidge (R)
Set-up: Ryan Madson (R)
Impact Arm: JC Romero (L) (if he’s still good without the juice)
The Rest: Chad Durbin (R), Scott Eyre (L), Clay Condrey (R), Adam Eaton (R)

[3] New York Mets
I haven’t had too many kind words for the choke artists over the years, but I will say they have put together a pretty good bullpen. Going out and getting the best closer available in Francisco Rodriguez was something they had to do with Billy Wagner being out for a long, long time. Then they went out and acquired another solid closer in JJ Putz to be their set-up man. Pretty good start. I do however have a bad feeling about Rodriguez. I can’t put my finger on it, but I just have the feeling Rodriguez is on the verge of completely burning out. His strikeout total took a big drop last and I just don’t know how much longer he has as an elite closer. His 62 saves last season was miraculous but I see troubles possibly late this season.
Closer: Francisco Rodriguez (R)
Set-up: JJ Putz (R)
Impact Arm: JJ Putz (R)
The Rest: Pedro Feliciano (L), Sean Green (R), Bobby Parnell (R), Duaner Sanchez (R)

[2] Minnesota Twins
Those on the outside looking in may not be very impressed with the Twins’ bullpen. Granted they don’t have the big arms they once had (Juan Rincon, Pat Neshek, etc), they do have some good young arms that can hold their own. They have Matt Guerrier and Jesse Crain ready to take the 7th and 8th innings as well as newly added Luis Ayala available to get hitters out. But the impact arm may be left handed rookie Jose Mijares who had a spectacular September call up last season posting a 0.87 ERA and 0.29 WHIP in 10 games and holding hitters to a .088 batting average. Oh and there’s always that Nathan guy who happens to be the best closer in baseball.
Closer: Joe Nathan (R)
Set-up: Jesse Crain (R)
Impact Arm: Jose Mijares (L)
The Rest: Matt Guerrier (R), Craig Breslow (L), Luis Ayala (R), Phil Humber (R)

[1] Boston Red Sox
We all know the intensity of Jonathan Papelbon and how lights out he has been. But it’s the rest of the group that can make or break them. The addition of Takashi Saito was huge as he gives the Sox a right handed set-up guy. This is especially important after Francona backed off using Hideki Okajima in close and late games down the stretch last season after a rough first half. Of course the wild card in all of this is the man who would be starting for most other teams in Justin Masterson if not for the Red Sox 19 veteran starting pitchers they have to choose between. If Okajima can bounce back, look out.
Closer: Jonathan Papelbon (R)
Set-up: Takashi Saito (R)
Impact Arm: Justin Masterson (R)
The Rest: Hideki Okajima (L), Manny Delcarmen (R), Javier Lopez (R), Ramon Ramirez (R)

By Matthew Whipps
The Diamond Cutter
Major & Minor League Baseball Columnist
diamondcutter@columnist.com

| | | |

Advertisements

4 Responses to 2009 Preview: Baseball’s Top Bullpens

  1. E K says:

    I have to say I am shocked you consider the Cubs bullpen in the top 5. I think it is their weak link and could be their downfall. I think Gregg is over-rated and don’t trust him one bit. Marmol needs to remain the 7th or 8th inning guy as I don’t think he can handle the closers duties. Plus, he is more valuable in his current role. The rest of the pen is sketchy at best. Samardzija might prove to be valuable, but I have no idea how good he’ll be this year. Cotts and Vizcaino…..not good. And Heilman and Gaudin are wild cards. The Cubs will need one, if not both, to step it up this year.

    Over-all I give them a C minus. They’ll need a lot to go there way…..

  2. You know, I toyed with it too as I think the Cubs bullpen has potential to be really good and potential to be really bad. The problem I ran into is that there really isn’t any reliever corps that I see as being that much better.

    The Yankees have an aging closer (who has still be good) and that’s it. Who knows where Joba will be and Marte was not good after the trade.

    The Angels are blah as I’m not a fan of Fuentes. Shields is fading and losing control of his command. Arredondo is the only guy I like.

    The Indians have Wood and you know how healthy he can be.

    The only real option might be the Rays with the fragile Percival, Wheeler, Balfour and Nelson but I’m not sure what to expect out of them as they could have just been playing out of their minds last season.

    I honestly can’t find another team that is so much better than the Cubs to rank them higher.

    If anyone has any ideas please let me know!

  3. Mike says:

    I would like to nominate the Oakland A’s bullpen. I know, I can hardly believe I’m saying it myself- still being haunted by the ghost of Ricardo Rincon and all, but we’ve got two potential closers, Joey Devine and that Ziegler character, an excellent 8th inning guy in Santiago Casilla (I believe that’s still his name this season), and we’ve even got Russ Springer. It seems like everyone in the bullpen started the season with 50 scoreless innings. We have power, youth, stamina and Russ Springer. Now if we can just get a lead for them to hold…..

  4. Mike says:

    Oh- and the Mets bullpen looks good on paper, but it’s the Mets. They’ll find a way to screw it up. Jesse Orosco and Roger McDowell are spinning in their graves. Or Atlanta. Wait- same thing.

%d bloggers like this: